Sunday, 20 December 2009

A not so noble Nobel?

I haven't seen a vast amount of comment on Obama's Nobel prize. Most commentators I have read seem to have been reserved. Not being effusive in their congratulations but not expressing too much doubt too. It's all been a bit neutral from what I can gather.

I think it's a poor do. He seems to have got it on a promise. A promise of what he might do based on the aims he has spoken about.

He hasn't achieved anything yet. A lot could happen during his remaining term of office.

If we got all rewarded on our promises rather than our achievements we would all be smothered with awards.

He got it because he is black. He got it because he wasn't George Bush. He got it because he was photogenic and could talk the talk......you know, those big portentous sounding speeches that sound great until you listen to the words and realise that they are full of the platitudes that all politicians use; especially the dishonest ones.

When he was elected I was shocked by the attitude of many of his supporters. It came over to me as racist at times. If he'd been white and white people had behaved in such a way it would have been seen as shocking.

Or if he'd been a Muslim?

He represents what politics has become. Image with no substance. Even if the man has substance that is not important any more. He got the Nobel not for substance but for image.

The substance of our lives is no longer governed by those with a political vision. There are no Churchills. There are no Hitlers either.

The people who influence our lives are in the boardrooms now. That is where the power lies. In the media too.

We have seen how they can affect our lives in a way that politicians can only dream of.

3 comments:

  1. I think Obama represents hope. I think he represents change, and I think he is probably embarrassed by the Nobel Peace prize, but to refuse it would have made him look like he could not deliver what we are all waiting for!
    ReplyDelete
  2. Hmmm maybe anon, to refuse it would have taken some courage and isn't that what we want from our leaders? The courage to do what they think is right rather than worry about the impression they give?

    I think that's one of the problems with politics these days; they all have more than a weather eye on their image and how they look.

    I think he could have refused it with a carefully worded explanation which would have made people sit up and take notice; making it clear that he had a job to do and that he should be judged for his actions not his aspirations etc etc

    Accepting it has devalued the prize and him in my view.
    ReplyDelete
  3. Totally agree. It's like giving Obama a lifetime achievement award.
    ReplyDelete

Bear in mind that there is NO COMMENT MODERATION here. Once posted you cannot delete or edit. I have found I don't need it, so polite are you all. If, like me, you have ten thumbs and end up posting some gobbledigook drop me a line.